top of page
Search

Humanitarian Needs in Ukraine

ABSTRACT

The Russia-Ukraine crisis garnered widespread attention in February 2023. However, historical records indicate that this crisis has deep roots in a longstanding conflict. The signing of the Budapest Memorandum in 1994, with the participation of two of the world's most influential nations, the USA and the UK, was meant to prevent the Russian Federation from using military force, economic pressure, or coercion against Ukraine, Belarus, and Kazakhstan. As part of the memorandum, Ukraine relinquished its nuclear weapons to Russia. The situation escalated with the annexation of Crimea in 2014, followed by the Minsk Agreement in the same year, and the declaration of independence for the Donbass region of Ukraine in 2015. These events collectively contributed to what has now become known as the most devastating war in history – the Russia-Ukraine War.


One year after Russia's invasion, Ukraine faces a severe humanitarian crisis due to the exodus of millions of refugees. This has triggered Europe's largest refugee crisis since WWII, pressuring neighbouring countries to host displaced people. As the conflict stretches into its second year without a solution, it becomes crucial to comprehend the specific type of assistance Ukraine needs to address the gaps in its losses, despite the influx of international aid.

 

The Report of UOCHA

The graph displayed above originates from the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UOCHA). It illustrates a notable increase in delivering aid to Ukraine during the ongoing conflict. However, a lingering question persists: Is this assistance effectively reaching the hands of the people it is intended for? According to this report, Humanitarian entities persist in their endeavours to provide assistance to individuals within Ukraine, having extended crucial aid and protective services to almost 7.3 million people by the conclusion of June. Yet, a mere 4 percent of those who benefited from aid inhabit regions within the jurisdiction of the Russian Federation – entry to these territories remains exceedingly constrained.


Additionally, the insufficiency of funding is impeding operational efforts, further exacerbating the hurdles posed by insecurity and other hindrances. Many countries and organisations have held their helping hands for the same. Significant contributions has also been made by India throughout. As of June 3, 2022, a total of 230 metric tonnes of humanitarian assistance, which comprises medicines, medical supplies, tents, blankets, and various relief items, have been provided. Furthermore, on September 12, 2022, an extra consignment of humanitarian aid, containing medicines and medical equipment, was transported, amounting to 7.7 metric tonnes. In April 2023, there was a commitment for additional humanitarian aid, with India making arrangements to dispatch school buses. Additional humanitarian assistance has been extended by international organizations such as the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), UNICEF, UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR), and the International Medical Corps, among others.


The data available indicates a substantial inflow of humanitarian assistance from diverse countries and organizations. Nevertheless, the question remains whether this aid is sufficient for Ukraine to fully recover from the extensive damages it has endured.

Source: Situation Reports | UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs


Shedding light on the diverse factors that could potentially account for this situation:

Magnitude of Destruction: While the data that shows by December 2022, the assessed cost of damage inflicted on Ukraine's infrastructure following Russia's full-scale invasion on February 24, 2022, stands at approximately $137.8 billion, depicts the extent of devastation, the qualitative depth of damage to critical infrastructure, housing, and essential services remains a technical enigma. This depth often surpasses the available resources and temporal horizons for recovery, necessitating intricate restoration procedures.


Displacement Dynamics: The staggering number of internally displaced persons (IDPs) due to conflict can strain available resources and challenge the efficiency of aid distribution. At least 12 million people have fled their homes since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the United Nations (UN) says. Technically, coordinating assistance and services for displaced populations while simultaneously rebuilding local communities is a complex task.


Turbulence in Political Fabric: The labyrinthine technicalities of navigating a fragmented political landscape yield challenges in swift decision-making and seamless coordination. The intricacies of political instability translate into tangible delays in imperative recovery deliberations and their execution.


Residual Trauma's Indelible Mark: The nuanced technical aspects of addressing mental health, restoring community dynamics, and nurturing social cohesion are frequently overshadowed. However, these intangible dimensions intricately impact human capital and the social fabric, impeding recovery's pace.


Media and Public Perception play a pivotal role in influencing the flow of aid by potentially distorting the portrayal of relief efforts and fostering negative public sentiment. When there is a misrepresentation of the actual aid initiatives or when negative perceptions about the effectiveness of aid prevail, it can significantly impact the willingness of donors to contribute, subsequently affecting the overall flow of assistance.


Addressing the issue of media and public perception requires a multi-faceted approach. Humanitarian organizations must proactively engage with the media to provide accurate information about their efforts, outcomes, and challenges. Transparency in aid operations can help build trust among the public and donors. Collaborating with journalists to ensure accurate reporting and sharing success stories can help counterbalance negative narratives.


In summation, the provision of humanitarian aid to Ukraine emerges as a complex and pivotal pursuit amidst the ongoing crisis. The inflow of resources, financial support, and global solidarity underscores the urgent need to alleviate the multifaceted suffering borne from conflict. This joint international response acknowledges the gravity of challenges posed by the crisis. However, the effective distribution of aid within a conflict-stricken environment entails intricate considerations. The convergence of logistical impediments, administrative complexities, security threats, and intricate socio-economic dynamics demands a meticulously strategized approach. The provision of aid extends beyond financial transactions; it demands an acute comprehension of ground realities, cultural nuances, and the precise requirements of the affected communities.


Successful humanitarian efforts rely on collaboration among international bodies, local authorities, NGOs, and affected communities. This ensures transparent aid distribution and efficient management. Effective communication and coordination optimize resources and adapt strategies. Amid Ukraine's crisis, where destruction, displacement, and conflict prevail, humanitarian aid's importance is heightened. This underscores that while funds are critical, understanding logistical, social, and cultural complexities is vital. Recovery demands sustained commitment and a focus on both technical and social intricacies. By aligning dedication with comprehension, Ukraine can emerge resilient and thriving from crisis.


References

  • Wikipedia, Budapest Referendum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum

  • OCHA, Ukraine Humanitarian Response (2023) https://reports.unocha.org/en/country/ukraine/

  • IndiaTimes (2022).

  • Livemint (2022) https://www.livemint.com/news/world/india-sends-7-725-kilograms-of-humanitarian-aid-to-ukraine-amid-war-read-here-11662994122487.html

  • Swaminathan (2023), Wion https://www.wionews.com/india-news/india-to-send-school-buses-to-ukraine-as-part-of-additional-humanitarian-aid-582114

  • Lawder and Gallagher (2022), Reuters https://www.reuters.com/world/world-bank-estimates-ukraine-physical-damage-roughly-60-billion-so-far-2022-04-21/

  • (2022) BBC News https://www.bbc.com/news/world-60555472

 

*This article was authored by Sabri Ranjan, Student from Symbiosis Law School, Noida and reviewed by Shreya Doneriya, Student from Symbiosis Law School, Noida.





Comentários

bottom of page