Decertifying Legal Sex: Pre-figurative Law Reform and the Future of Legal Gender

ABSTRACT

The Special issue titled, “Challenging Legal Sex Classification – Prefigurative Law Reforms and the Evolution of Gender Identity in Legal Contexts.”

The issue appears to focus on a critical examination of the concept of Decertifying Legal Sex and its implications within the context of legal and identified gender frameworks. Decertifying Legal Sex refers to the idea of challenging or dismantling the traditional legal classifications and categorizations of individuals based on their sex or gender.

This special issue is all about the arguments and disagreements around the idea of getting rid of the official categories of male and female in the law in Britain, particularly in England and Wales. It looks closely at why this idea came about, which includes things like people fighting for transgender rights and changes in how we think about equality. This all started with new laws around the world that wanted to recognize different genders and help people change their gender legally. Even though these laws are trying to include more gender options, they still mostly stick to the idea of having only two genders, like male and female. But this raises an important question: Why do we need legal categories for gender at all? This special issue talks about a project called the 'Future of Legal Gender' that started in 2018. They're trying to figure out if there's a good reason to keep these legal categories for gender in England and Wales.

Keywords: Decertification, Gender, Legal Reforms, Status.

---

Analysis

Lets’s dwelve into the historical background of Legal Recoginition of Certified Sex at birth. Some societies have started to formally recognize non-binary, genderqueer, or third gender identities in recent years. It may not (or may have very recently) included internationally-recognized 'legal rights' for such persons, although certain non-western countries have long recognized transgender people as a third gender. This has much more to do with the nature of the legal system towards gender than the nature of the societies towards it, as referenced by the distinctive cultural place and societal privileging members of the third gender in non-Western societies which recognize them—five examples being pre-colonial Inca Qariwarmi, Pali pandakas, androgynes in the Talmud, Hijras as described further below, and the Inuit 'third gender'. With the issuance of an intersex passport to Alex MacFarlane in 2003 and the recognition of a third classification among western countries, Australia may have been the first. In 2014, Norrie May-Welby, a proponent of transgender rights, was acknowledged as having an ambiguous status. Elisa Rae Shupe was granted legal non-binary gender transition in 2016 by a circuit court in Oregon.

The articles explore various aspects of decertification, its potential impact, and its relationship with feminist perspectives. Each article delves into different aspects of this topic, ranging from its implications for gender-based hierarchies, its effects on single-sex services like education, attitudes toward legal gender reform, challenges posed by "soft decertification," and the conceptual and discursive power of experimental statutes.

"Pulling the thread of decertification" By Davina Cooper and Robyn Emerton

This article focuses on Examining hopes, politics, and concerns related to decertification as a mechanism to de-formalize sex/gender. Evaluates decertification's potential contributions to feminist politics and its methodological value for research. Explores decertification in comparison to recognizing multiple gender identities.

Source: http://surl.li/lvwgt

"The challenge of same sex provision" By Flora Renz

Focus: Analyzes the potential challenges posed by decertification to single-sex services, especially in education. Explores the reasons for single-sex education, legal rights, inclusion of trans and non-binary pupils, and the adaptability of schools to different interpretations of gender.

"Gender’s wider stakes" By Elizabeth Peel and Hannah Newman

Focus: Analyzing attitudes toward legal gender reform through a survey. Discusses everyday experiences and understandings of gender, and explores concepts of cisgenderism and endosexism as frameworks to understand people's gender attitudes.

"Taking public responsibility for gender" By Davina Cooper

Focus: Explores the implications of "soft decertification," where gender is treated differently in public and private contexts. Discusses challenges for equality initiatives and the complexities of responsibility for gender in different contexts, such as public sector provision and organizational actions.

"Exploring the textual alchemy of legal gender" By Emily Grabham

Focus: Examines the politics of writing an experimental feminist statute to decertify gender. Discusses the power of statutory text and its relationship with changing gender norms. Explores the method's impact on feminist scholars and legislative drafting practices.

Conclusion

In summary, articles seem to cover a range of perspectives, exploring the complexities and implications of decertification as a potential mechanism to address gender-related issues. They engage with various aspects, including legal, political, social, and feminist dimensions, shedding light on the challenges and opportunities that decertification presents. The articles collectively aim to contribute to a critical understanding of gender norms, practices, and the role of law in shaping them.

The question arosed with reference to the above article:

Q) What might be the consequences if people are no longer legally classified as female or male based on a sex registered at birth?

The question arose points towards Decertification - refers to a situation in which state law steps back from recording, confirming, recognizing, or standing behind sex/ gender. In simple words, it means dismantling legal sex and gender status classified as male and female at birth.

---

*This article was authored by Riya Chouhan, Student from Symbiosis Law School, Noida and reviewed by Pihoo Agrawal, Student from Symbiosis Law School, Noida.